What Is Affray? Definition, Sentence and What to Expect if Charged

If you have been arrested or charged with affray, the first thing you need is a plain explanation of what the offence is, how it is sentenced, and what your next steps should be.

Affray is a public order offence under section 3 of the Public Order Act 1986. It is committed when a person uses or threatens unlawful violence in a way that would cause a hypothetical bystander of "reasonable firmness" to fear for their personal safety.

It is an either-way offence triable in the Magistrates' or Crown Court, with a maximum sentence of three years' imprisonment when heard in the Crown Court. Only one person needs to use or threaten violence for an affray charge to apply, and the offence can be committed in public or in private.

We discuss the offence of affray in detail in the following guide, including what actions can amount to affray and what the current sentencing guidelines for affray look like.

For urgent help with allegations of affray, speak to our criminal defence team.

What is affray under UK law?

Affray is defined in section 3 of the Public Order Act 1986. To prove affray, the prosecution must show that:

• The defendant used or threatened unlawful violence towards another person.
• The conduct was such that a person of reasonable firmness, if present at the scene, would have feared for their safety.

Threats that are made by the use of words alone do not constitute affray.

The "person of reasonable firmness" is hypothetical. No one actually needs to have been present and put in fear, which is why affray can be charged on the basis of CCTV, body-worn video, or police evidence, even when no civilian victim has come forward. The offence of Affray can be committed in both a private and a public place.

Affray differs from assault. Assault is an offence against an individual; affray is an offence against public peace. That is why an affray charge can stand even when no one was physically injured.

An affray cannot simply be directed at property or words alone.

What counts as affray? Examples

Conduct charged as affray typically includes:

• Fighting in a public place such as a street, pub, station, or transport hub.
• Brandishing a knife, bottle, bat, or other weapon in a threatening manner.
• Sustained group disorder outside a venue after closing time.
• Throwing objects indiscriminately into a crowd.
• Violent confrontation at a sporting event or protest.
• A serious disturbance in a private home where the conduct would have caused a bystander to fear for their safety.

Words alone do not amount to affray. There must be a physical act or gesture of violence. Where two or more people are fighting, the conduct of each is considered separately, and one person being charged does not automatically mean others will be.

Affray vs violent disorder vs riot

Affray sits within a hierarchy of public order offences.

Affray is the most commonly charged of the three because it does not require collective action. One person, acting alone, can be charged if their conduct meets the statutory test.

Affray vs ABH and common assault

Affray is often confused with assault offences, but the legal frameworks differ. Common assault and actual bodily harm (ABH) are offences against the person and require evidence of unwanted contact or injury to an identified victim. Affray requires no victim to come forward; the prosecution must satisfy the court that a hypothetical bystander would have feared for their safety.

For a detailed comparison, including how sentencing ranges compare in practice, see our guide Is affray worse than ABH?.

How serious is affray?

Affray is a serious offence, particularly when you consider the sentencing guidelines that apply to cases which are heard in both the Magistrates’ and Crown Courts.

The punishment for affray could have a major impact on your life and livelihood, which highlights the importance of having experienced legal counsel on your side if you are charged.

A conviction also has long-term consequences. Affray is "non-filterable", which means a caution or conviction appears on standard and enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks indefinitely. This can affect employment, professional regulation, travel visas, and family proceedings.

Affray sentencing guidelines

Affray is an either-way offence, meaning it can be heard in either the Magistrates’ or Crown Court. The court applies the Sentencing Council guideline on affray, which assesses culpability and harm, identifies a starting point and category range, then adjusts for aggravating and mitigating factors.

Culpability categories

• Culpability A: targeting of individuals by a group, use of a weapon to inflict violence, sustained or serious violence, or intention to cause fear of very serious violence.
• Culpability B: threat of violence with any weapon (whether or not produced), and/or threat or use of violence falling between A and C.
• Culpability C: minimal violence, and/or conduct in self-defence or fear of violence that does not amount to a full defence.

Harm categories

• Category 1: serious physical injury to others and/or serious fear and distress caused.
• Category 2: harm falling between categories 1 and 3.
• Category 3: little or no physical injury, with some fear or distress caused.

Each combination of culpability and harm produces a starting point for sentencing. A Culpability A / Category 1 offence will sit close to the statutory maximum, while a Culpability C / Category 3 offence will attract a more lenient sentence.

Credit for a guilty plea

The Sentencing Council guideline on reduction in sentence for a guilty plea allows up to a one-third reduction for a guilty plea indicated at the first stage of proceedings. The reduction tapers to one quarter after the first stage of proceedings, and to a maximum of one tenth on the first day of trial. See our guide to credit for a guilty plea for more information.

Defences to an affray charge

The most common defences to affray charges include:

• Self-defence or defence of another. Reasonable force to protect yourself, someone else, or property, or to prevent someone from carrying out a crime. The force must be proportionate to the threat as the defendant genuinely believed it to be. See our guide on self-defence as a legal defence.
• The conduct did not meet the statutory test. Heated arguments, verbal exchanges, or minor scuffles may not be enough to cause a hypothetical bystander to fear for their safety.
• Mistaken identification. Affray often arises from group disorder, where CCTV is poor and witness accounts conflict. Showing that the defendant was not involved, or was acting as a peacemaker, can defeat the charge.
• Lack of the required mental element. The prosecution must prove that the defendant intended to use or threaten violence, or was aware that their conduct may have been violent.

Defence strategies for affray are built around specific evidence, such as CCTV, body-worn video, witness statements, custody records, and forensic material. Early instruction allows that evidence to be challenged at the right stage.

Can affray charges be dropped or reduced to a caution?

Yes. Affray charges can be dropped pre-charge, at the post-charge review, or during proceedings if the evidence does not meet the CPS Full Code Test. Our guide to getting the CPS to drop the charges against you explains the process.

A caution may be offered to a first-time offender for low-level conduct, but only where the defendant admits the offence and consents. A caution avoids a conviction yet still creates a permanent record on the Police National Computer and is disclosable indefinitely on enhanced DBS checks. It should not be accepted without legal advice.

What happens after an affray arrest: step by step

• Arrest and detention. You will be taken to a police station. You are entitled to free, independent legal advice in custody. Request a solicitor before any interview.
• Police interview under caution. This is the single most important stage. Anything said, or a no-comment interview given without instruction, can be used in evidence. A prepared statement is often the right course, but only after a solicitor has reviewed disclosure.
• Decision to charge or release. The custody sergeant, or in more serious cases the CPS, decides whether to charge, release under investigation, pre-charge bail, or take no further action.
• First hearing in the Magistrates' Court. If charged, a plea is indicated at the first hearing. Maximum credit for a guilty plea (one third) is preserved by entering the plea at this stage.
• Venue decision. As affray is an either-way offence, the court decides whether the case is heard summarily or sent to the Crown Court.
• Case preparation. The prosecution serves disclosure. The defence reviews evidence, instructs experts where needed, takes detailed witness statements, and prepares the defence statement.
• Trial or sentence. A contested trial is heard before a jury in the Crown Court, or summarily by magistrates. On conviction, the court applies the sentencing guideline.

Does affray show on a DBS check?

Yes. Affray is one of a list of offences that are never filtered from a DBS check, regardless of how long ago the caution or conviction was. A standard or enhanced DBS check will disclose affray indefinitely.

This is the most common reason clients want to contest an affray charge rather than accept a caution, particularly where their work involves regulated roles, healthcare, the financial sector, education, or family contact.

Frequently asked questions about affray

Is affray worse than ABH?

Affray and ABH cannot be ranked directly because they are different offences. Affray carries a maximum of three years' imprisonment; ABH carries a maximum of five. In practice, however, the sentence that is handed out for both offences depends on a range of factors, including culpability, harm and the presence of any mitigating or aggravating factors. Our dedicated guide, 'Is Affray Worse than ABH? sets out the comparison in detail.

What is the maximum sentence for affray?

The maximum sentence for affray on conviction on indictment is three years' imprisonment. As affray is an either-way offence, if the case is heard in the Magistrates' Court, the maximum sentence is 12 months' custody.

How many people need to be involved in affray?

Only one person needs to use or threaten unlawful violence for an affray charge to stand. If three or more are involved, the charge may be elevated to violent disorder. Twelve or more acting with a common purpose may be charged with riot.

Can you be cautioned for affray?

Yes, in narrow circumstances. A caution is typically offered to first-time offenders for low-level conduct, requires an admission, and is permanent on the Police National Computer. Affray cautions appear on enhanced DBS checks indefinitely, so take advice before accepting one.

What should you do if you have been charged with affray?

Instruct a specialist criminal defence solicitor before your first court appearance. Preserve any CCTV, phone footage, and witness contact details. Do not discuss the incident on social media or with potential witnesses. Early intervention is the single biggest factor in challenging affray charges effectively.

Contact our affray solicitors today

For urgent specialist advice, immediate representation or to speak to us confidentially about affray or any other serious crime case, please do not hesitate to contact our dedicated team of criminal defence lawyers in London, Birmingham and Manchester by telephone:

• London Central - Head Office: 020 7624 7771
• West Hampstead Office: 020 7624 7771 
• Manchester Office: 0161 835 1638
• Birmingham Office: 0121 614 333

Or email: solicitors@jdspicer.co.uk

Alternatively, you can fill out our quick online enquiry form and we will get back to you as soon as possible.

24/7 legal representation for affray offences

For immediate representation and advice, you can contact our emergency number 07836 577556 and we will provide you with the urgent assistance you need.